LYF’s Smallholder Support Network Demonstrates Real Impact with Kenyan Coffee Smallholders

One of the biggest problems facing poor smallholders in developing countries is their lack of access to relevant, affordable and timely information on agri-business issues, especially in relation to export markets. This impacts on their ability to engage fairly within both local and global trade.

At the same time, the challenges of climate change, food security and increased pressure on natural resources means that the buyers, exporters and certification schemes urgently need to engage with hundreds of thousands of smallholders around the world on these issues – which also directly affect the farmers’ livelihoods.

The Smallholder Support Network (SSN) was set up by the Lorna Young Foundation in 2010 in order to address the training and information needs of smallholder organisations around the world. The ultimate aim of the SSN is to equip poor smallholders with greater levels of unbiased knowledge and understanding of the markets that they sell to. The SSN works on the premise that improved crop husbandry will lead to greater yields and quality. These are the factors that will lead to improved prices for produce over the long term and which will result in more sustainable livelihoods and a reduction in poverty in developing countries.

Working out of Ethiopia and Kenya – LYF’s pilot countries for the SSN –  an unusual and empowering approach has been created.  The SSN has created a dialogue directly with smallholder populations via RADIO, SMS and INTERNET platforms.  These technologies deliver real LIVE TIME updates on issues affecting smallholder crops and livelihoods. At the current time, the SSN’s focus is on coffee farming and in March, this month, for the first time ever, an exchange visit of Kenyan coffee board members will take place in Ethiopia, so that training and exchange of information in relation to the  international coffee industry can occur. The SSN’s Radio Agriculture Extension Officer, Joseph Macharia, will be following 4 coffee board members as they travel throughout the supply chain in Ethiopia.  They will meet millers, auctioneers, tasters, sales and marketing experts and buyers and will learn about the international coffee trade, with the new knowledge being brought back to Kenya via the SSN Radio broadcasts – hosted by the Kenyan Broadcasting Corporation’s channel Coro FM.

The Communication Challenge

Over the past 6 months the SSN has collaborated with a wide range of stakeholders throughout its SSN Radio broadcasts in Kenya – including certification schemes, exporters, coffee buyers, NGOs and government bodies, with the express purpose of ensuring that smallholders are receiving  information that is timely, relevant and up to date.

Unlike some other initiatives, the SSN does not believe in the dissemination of biased information i.e.  ‘training’ which pushes any one production approach or certification scheme, which all too often are made up of content which is more important to the big business or to the stakeholders involved in the industry and their own sales figures.  Rather, it is about developing a two way dialogue with smallholders in rural farming communities. One of the major objectives of the SSN has always been to empower smallholder organisations to make better business decisions with the buyers of their products. The SSN is now achieving this by developing smallholders’ understanding of ethical certification, sustainable agriculture, supply chains, export markets, business requirements and international trade.

The SSN uses an SMS platform to develop the dialogue; smallholders send their questions on the coffee industry to the SSN Radio Programme and they are answered by a team of experts working in the coffee industry. This approach is truly empowering. It provides smallholders with a voice and an opportunity to engage more effectively with one another, with agricultural extension services, development organisations and with the buyers and even the consumers of their produce.

How the SSN works

Working with Agricultural Extension Officers in Kenya, the SSN targets coffee smallholders via the medium of RADIO, assisting them with learning on key issues, such as quality, yields, climate change and food security. These broadcasts are now reaching  an audience of 4.5 million people and some 500,000 coffee farmers via Kenya’s Coro FM. SSN’s ‘Farmers Gold’ or ‘DhahabuYaMurimi’ as it is known in the local Kikuyu language, is the first Radio Programme of its kind that brings together a multi stakeholder platform –of ‘specialised’ NGOs, buyers, exporters, research and training institutes with the express purpose of reaching smallholders. After being delivered via the airwaves – the Radio broadcasts are then uploaded onto the internet, where they can be accessed as podcasts at any time.

As an overall approach, the SSN essentially has 3 key components:

1) Farmer Field Listening Groups: Two groups of 15 farmers from 2 different coffee cooperatives (the ‘Rumukia’ and the ‘Gikanda’ Coffee Cooperatives) make up the Farmer Field Listening Groups and act as the SSN pilot ‘listeners’. As individuals they are committed to raising queries via SMS, but as a collective they also work together  to generate content for the radio programmes and to ensure that its content addresses the key concerns of coffee smallholders.

2)     Multi-stakeholder Platforms: The SSN has adopted a multi-stakeholder approach in order to ensure that farmers have the most up to date and important facts, on a broad spectrum of issues and from reliable sources. The SSN brings together a platform of coffee stakeholders such as millers, buyers, agricultural extension staff and development specialists in the supply chain to generate information on issues affecting smallholders livelihoods (i.e. prices, volume requirements, pests, diseases, diversification, food security, droughts, weather, sustainable agriculture). The stakeholders are responsible for answering smallholder questions via the live feedback facility which relies on communication from farmers through SMS text messaging. Every week, 5 key questions which have been generated via SMS are addressed in the radio programme.

3) Radio: Specialised agricultural extension staff with radio experience deliver 10 minute weekly programmes addressing key topics such as:

a) the Agricultural Calendar (cropping, fertilising, harvesting)

b) Markets (price, quality, volume)

c) Certification requirements (wages, PPE, environmental standards)

d) Climate Change (food security, diversification, sustainable agricultural practices).

e) Weather information

f) Agriculture news (coffee news)

g) Gender issues

The radio programmes are aired on prime time vernacular radio, in the evening in order to facilitate access to information for women. These programmes are then translated and made available as podcasts through the SSN portal. It seems that the genuine ‘grassroots generated’ nature of the content – accompanied by ‘answers from the experts’ has been a key factor in engaging the attention of smallholders across this region of Kenya.

Real Dialogue about Fair Trade Choices

Great article from Chris Bacon, discussing the future of Fair Trade; and some real dialogue about Fair Trade choices

http://www.foodfirst.org/sites/www.foodfirst.org/files/pdf/The_struggle_for_food_justice_in_Fair_Trade_2011-12.pdf

What Impact the Coffee Industry on Producer Countries?

This interesting article explores the impact of the coffee industry at origin. Worth a read.

http://coffeelands.crs.org/2012/01/2012-the-year-of-the-impact-at-origin-baseline/

 

Join the Fairtrade Debate

With Fairtrade reaching 25 years, there is a growing debate about its future, its direction and its place in trade justice. This Guardian article provides an interesting insight to the issues and invites readers’ views

http://www.guardian.co.uk/global-development/2012/feb/01/fair-trade-ethical-debate-fairtrade?newsfeed=true

Ethiopian Coffee Farmers Still Facing Injustice

This short blog post brings in to focus the injustice that small farmers in Ethiopia still face – has anything really changed in the industry despite the efforts of the ethical trade movement and the exposure from Black Gold and others. We can make drive better trading practice but there has to be the will to do it from the industry and this needs to be driven be consumers.

http://www.blackgoldfoundation.org/ethiopian-coffee-farmers-still-facing-injustice

The OCC and Abiyot

Here at the LYF we are really proud of the Oromo Coffee Company. With our Oromo colleagues and other supporters, we set the OCC and, although it’s still a struggle for everyone involved, it’s still going and growing. A truly unique and wonderful social enterprise. This article tells the story of the OCC and of Abiyot, one of the founding members and the most dedicated member of the team. Whilst trying to study at university, he still commits all his spare time to making a success of the OCC.

http://voice-online.co.uk/article/against-all-odds

Are worker cooperatives a more sustainable business model in these economic times?

This BBC Radio 4 programme examines worker co-ops in the UK and internationally and asks whether, in these tough times, with high levels of mistrust of business, co-ops are a better solution for the future. http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b0196tn9/In_Business_All_Together_Now/

How Much Coffee do the Big Boys Buy?

Graphic showing Coffee Buying By Corporations

The major Food Corporations – Sara Lee, Kraft, Nestle and Starbucks buy huge quantities of coffee each year. This graphic helps to put this in context and shows how much of it is (or is not) fair trade.

Interesting Blog about Coffee, Trade and the USA

http://www.octopusgourmet.com/coffee/fair-trade-coffee-why-was-the-united-states-such-a-late-bloomer/

Should Fair Trade Certify Corporates Like Nestle?

There is a growing debate about the direction that Fair Trade certification bodies are taking, fuelled by the recent split by Fair Trade USA from FLO. This article focusses on the issues.

http://motherjones.com/tom-philpott/2011/11/nestle-folger-fair-trade